This week we take a look at a book I read in May 2024. John Boyne’s Earth. You may recall my review of Water in 2023. This is the second novella in this series of four. I understand the third book is also due to be published in 2024. These four books are loosely connected but I don’t think you need to read them in a certain order. The protagonist of Earth was a very minor character in Water. I think these books are more connected by theme than plot or characters.
Let’s get into it..
Earth is a gripping exploration of the complexities surrounding accusations of sexual crimes and the societal treatment of both victims and perpetrators. (Please check the trigger warnings!) Known for his ability to tackle difficult subjects with sensitivity and depth, Boyne delivers a powerful narrative that is thought-provoking and emotionally charged.
The story revolves around Evan Keogh, a professional footballer whose life is turned upside down when he is accused of a sexual crime. As the trial unfolds, Evan reflects on the events that have led him to this moment. Since leaving his island home, his life has been a lie on many levels: he’s a talented footballer who wanted to be an artist, a gay man in a sport that rejects diversity, and a defendant whose knowledge of what took place on that fateful night threatens more than just his freedom or career.
The novel is set against the sensational backdrop of a high-profile court case involving two well-known footballers, with the media frenzy adding to the pressure and public scrutiny. Through Evan’s journey, Boyne delves into the harsh realities of public opinion, media scrutiny, and the often-precarious balance of justice.
I am a huge fan of Boyne’s work so my expectations are always high. Earth did not disappoint. Boyne expertly explores themes of identity, integrity, and societal expectations. Evan Keogh is a complex protagonist, struggling to reconcile his true self with the persona he has adopted to fit into the world of professional football. His inner turmoil is palpable as he grapples with his desires, fears, and the consequences of his actions.
The novel also addresses the toxic culture within the world of professional sports, where masculinity and homophobia can often overshadow talent and individuality. Boyne doesn't shy away from depicting the dark side of fame and the pressure athletes face to conform to certain stereotypes. With this depiction comes a very confronting book for the reader. I do love some moral ambiguity! Evan is such a flawed and relatable character, and as I was reading the book I found myself feeling for Evan – I think this shows the real skill of Boyne in that we can feel so much for an alleged perpetrator of a crime, particularly through a novella. All of this unfolds in 168 pages. I think this book will have you grappling with your own sense of fairness. I know I was really challenged by this book (in a good way!)
In true Boyne style, the writing is stunning. The narrative alternates between the present-day courtroom drama and flashbacks to Evan's past. I love this structure in books as it always keeps me engaged, builds suspense, and builds real depth of character. This adds to the empathy felt for Evan.
As well as being a beautifully written book, this novel raises critical questions about guilt, innocence, and the societal impulse to judge before understanding. Earth is a powerful and necessary read that sheds light on the complexities of sexual crime accusations and the societal treatment of those involved. This may be a difficult read for many (for obvious reasons) and it is often quite emotionally tense. If this is not a subject matter that you may find difficult, definitely pick this one up. I highly recommend this book to those who appreciate contemporary fiction that tackle challenging subjects with sensitivity because life is too short to read bad books.